[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Coil form material - Q-killer?
Original poster: Jim Lux <jimlux@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
At 05:56 PM 1/9/2007, you wrote:
Original poster: "Gav D" <gdingley@xxxxxxxxx>
Hi Ed, Jim, Mike
thanks for that information, I will alter my PSpice simulation
accordingly. Were either of you able to measure the Q directly, i.e.
before breakout occurs during operation? I have attempted this by
recording the waveform digitally and performing an FFT, but I think in
the end I was just testing the effectiveness of the FFT! I should
resort to more analogue methods, and suggestions/ideas?
Terry did some of those measurements, gosh, 5-10 years ago. He put a
secondary out in the garage and pinged it with an impulse and
digitized the waveform to measure Q variations with temperature and
humidity. Maybe he'll pipe up with a pointer to the data.
I retrieved a paper written by Wheeler on calculating skin-effect
resistance, a methodology rather than a formula, i.e. it can be
applied to any conductor geometry. All you actually do is take the
formula for the inductance (e.g. the much used Wheeler formula for
example), differentiate it by the direction in which the current will
most predominantly flow (radius r in the case of the Wheeler
inductance formula), divide by mu, and multiply by the skin-effect
constant for that material at the particular frequency of operation.
The results look OK, but I have not done any actual measurements to
verify it. I will try and scan the Wheeler paper and find my copy of
the Medhurst .zip file.
What's the reference? I can probably get it from the library at work.